People across the world are adapting to working and studying remotely due to COVID-19.  Hence the need for fast, reliable, uninterrupted internet. Whether you to continue to work from home or are moving back to the office, studying from home, or meeting family and friends online, this pandemic has created a rise in the need for internet services all around the country.

In order to have a strategic edge over the competition and their offering, Smile Uganda introduced new affordable internet bundles in the market. However MTN has captured a larger number of subscribers in Uganda having registered 12.6 million subscribers in the month of May 2020. This is due to their wide network coverage across the country and also their range of products, including Internet, voice services, and mobile money. Customers in Uganda are focused on quality and convenience of services and not technology being used

 

While Smile is at the forefront in 4G LTE offerings in Uganda other mobile network operators (MNOs) such as Airtel, Africell, Lyca mobile, and MTN joined the 4G LTE race much later. Smile has continued to be the market leader in offering the largest 4G LTE coverage in areas of Wakiso, Mukono, Mbarara, Masaka, Masindi, Fort Portal, Kabale, Gulu, Lira, Soroti, Mbale, Jinja, and Tororo.

Competitors have used this to their advantage since they provide both 4G LTE and 3G access around the country making their internet coverage wider.

 

Smile was the first and is the only company in Uganda to launch VoLTE on its network. This works directly with VoLTE-enabled handsets or through the use of the free mobile app; SmileVoice, that enables customers with any Android or Apple iPhone devices (including those which are not VoLTE-enabled) to make SuperClear voice calls over Smile’s 4G LTE network.

Smile Voice is a unique service in the market however, Ugandans have limited knowledge about this service and how it works. Competitors are leading because of wide network coverage and the amount of knowledge about the perceived easy-of-use of their voice services. MTN and Airtel networks have penetrated both urban and rural areas providing their customers with tailor-made offers for both voice and internet services.

 

In assessing the best mobile data provider and the experience in terms of performance, the primary focus is on the internet access devices including Routers and MIFI devices. These devices provided by Smile are 4G LTE compatible and connect Laptops, Smartphones, Smart TVs, and tablets seamlessly to its 4G LTE network. 4G LTE is more than 10 times faster than 3G;

 

To assess and analyse the Router and MiFi devices’ performance levels, we must understand the specifications for all the devices. For instance, what is the device model, item height and width, wireless type, and depth of the Routers. For portable the MiFi devices, it would be important to evaluate the weight, control, power supply, concurrent user connection, operating system (OS), range, modem speed, frequency, and security.

 

MiFi devices are small, portable, wireless-enabled devices that let multiple users and mobile devices share a mobile broadband internet connection. A MiFi enables you to connect multiple devices to a single 4G LTE connecting to get you online whilst on the move. Unlike your Smartphone’s data capabilities, MiFi devices are designed with strong signal capabilities to the point that your device can rarely slip to 2G unless in a remote area.

 

On the other hand a Wi-Fi Router, is a mid-sized console that is usually mounted in a single stable place providing strong signals to all connected devices. Although the device is bigger compared to MiFi devices, this gadget offers multiple features. As most Ugandans are still working from home, there is a real demand for a more fixed connection at home and the need to connect multiple devices including TVs, PCs and mobile phones.   A comparison of the routers of four data services provider indicates the leading providers in Uganda.

 

 

 

COMPARISON OF THE ROUTERS

ROUTER MTN SMILE AIRTEL AFRICEL
Model Huawei LTE B315 SM B940-4GLTE ROUTER ZTE MF283 DWR-921 4G LTE
Item Height 186 mm 200 mm 195 mm 90mm
Item Width 139 mm 157 mm 150 mm 116mm
Depth 46 mm 56 mm 55 mm 22.4 mm
Weight 275g 483g   295 g
Wireless Type 802.11b/g/n 802.11b/g/n 802.11b/g/n 802.11n/g/b
Control Power Button, Reset Button Power Button, Reset Button   Power button, WPS button connection

Reset button

In The Box LTE CPE B315,r

DC/AC Power adapter

RJ45 Cable

2 Antenna User Manual External Normal

LTE CPE Router (B940)

DC/AC Power Adapter UK RJ45 Cable User Manual External Normal

Antennas (4 PCS) 3M External Antennas (available for purchase)

Antennas (2)

Ethernet cable,

DC/AC power adaptor

CPE router

DWR-921 4G LTE Router

DC/AC Power Adapter

2 Antenna

RJ45 Cable and manual

Power Supply DC 12 V, 1 A DC 12 V, 1 A DC 12.0V 1.0A Max DC 12 V, 1 A
Battery   5200mAh In Built battery    3000mAH removable
OS  

Windows XP SP3, Windows 8

Windows Vista, Windows 7, Windows 8.1 MAC,

Windows 10,

 

Windows XP SP3, Windows 8

Windows Vista, Windows 7, Windows 8.1 MAC,

Windows 10,

 Windows XP SP3, Windows 8

Windows Vista, Windows 7, Windows 8.1 MAC,

Windows 10,

 

 

 Windows XP SP3, Windows 8

Windows Vista, Windows 7, Windows 8.1 MAC,

Windows 10,

 

 

Features Port Forwarding

DHCP

Network
parameters , like rsrq, rsrp ,pci , sinr

MAC Filtering

USB port

IP pass through

Port Forwarding

Remote access

Data usage statistics (showing timestamp, rx and tx)

Data usage cap

DHCP to use for time setting

Speed Allocation

Network  parameters , like rsrq, rsrp, pci, sinr:

MAX Filtering

USB port

Cloud hotspot compatibility via developed user interface

Doesn’t permit remote access for CCTV cameras configured with a static IP for remote view on mobile devices

 

 

 

 

 

Port Forwarding

DHCP

Network
parameters , like rsrq, rsrp ,pci , sinr

MAC Filtering

USB port

Cloud management access

Number of concurrent connections Up to 32 devices Up to 32 devices, WiFi, 4 LAN Ports / 1 WAN Port Up to 32 devices ,WiFi, 4 LAN ports, USB Up to 32 users via WiFi, 4 LAN ports
Range 100m 100m 100 M Up to 25-30 metres in an open environment.
DSL Modem Speed 150Mbps 100 Mbps 150 Mbps 300 Mbps
LAN/WAN       Fast Ethernet WAN + 4 x Fast Ethernet LAN
WiFi Frequency 2.4 GHz 2.4 GHz 2.4 GHz  2.4 GHz
LTE Frequency B7/B20B20 B7/B20 B7/B20  
Chipset ZTE ZTE ZTE  
Antenna 2 Antennae ,LTE 4 Antennae (2 WiFi,2 LTE 2 Antennae ,LTE Two detachable LTE/4G/3G antennas (3dBi gain). Two internal Wi-Fi antennas (3dBi gain)
Speed HSDPA/ HSUPA/ HSPA+ LTE / UMTS / GSM 150Mbps LTE TDD Cat 6 DL 150Mbps UL 50Mbps LTE TDD Cat 4 UMTS; GSM; HSPA+ 150Mbps
  DL 220+Mb/s UL 11+Mb/s    
Security wpa, wpa2 wpa, wpa2, wpa2- psk WEP  
wpa2- pskWeb Web URL Filter WPA, WPA2 In-built URL web filters for web-site restriction
URL Filter Firewall Firewall Firewall  
 DMZ Parental Control Web URL filters  
Antennae Capacity High gain Directional Omni Directional High gain Directional High gain directional

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

COMPARISON OF MIFI DEVICES

MIFI AIRTEL SMILE MTN AFRICEL LYCA MOBILE
Model Mf927u MiFi LT300+ 5200 Mah power bank MiFi router M028at Notion M028AT
Voltage 3,8V Limited charge voltage: 4,35V Standard: GB / T 18287 3.5-4.2V 4.2V 3.7V 3.7V
Dimensions 78mm x 78mm x 14.5mm. 100g. 93 x 59 x 14.4mm 15 x 10 x 30mm 98 x 63.5 x 13.6mm 98 x 63.5 x 13.6mm
Weight 100g   200g  130g (including the battery) 130g (including the battery)
Battery 6800mAh ( Lio battery can be  used as power bank) 3200mAh 5200mAh 2050mAh 2050mAh
Average Battery Standby Life Up to 6 hours, standby mode up to 200 hours 300 hours (12.5 days) Up to 15 hours, standby mode up to 100 hours Up to 9 hours, standby mode up to 100 hours Up to 9 hours, standby mode up to 100 hours
Battery Charge Time 4 hours   4 hours 5 hours
Included Components Device, Battery and charger cable Device, Battery, USB cable, Charger Adaptor/cable, Keyring and Strap Device, Charger Adaptor/ Cable Device, Battery and Charger Adaptor/ Cable Device, Battery and Charger Adaptor/ Cable
OS Win8, Win7, WinXP

MacOS, Android supported

Win7, Win8, WinXP

MacOS, Android supported

Win7, Win8, Win8.1, WinXP, MacOS, Android supported Wi7, Win 8, Win8.1, Win10, MacOS Android supported Win7, Win8, Win8.1, Win10, MacOS Android supported

 

Number of Connections 10 users (+1 USB tethering) 10 users (+1 USB tethering) 10 users (+1 USB tethering) 10 users (+1 USB tethering) 11 users (+1 USB tethering)
Screen No screen LCD screen (with colours) LCD Screen LCD Screen LCD Screen
HSDPA/ HSUPA/ HSPA+ LTE-FDD band: B1/B3/B5/B7/B8/B20/28 Band FDD B3/7/20 or FDD B28 or FDD B1/B3/B5   FDD Band 7 & 20 2600/800MHz) LTE FDD 3GPP R9, Category 4, DL 150Mbps UL 50Mbps UMTS/HSPA+ Band: 1 and 5 FDD Band 7 & 20 2600/800MHz) LTE FDD 3GPP R9, Category 4, DL 150Mbps UL 50Mbps UMTS/HSPA+ Band: 1 and 6
  LTE –TDD band: B38 (or B40) B41- 2555-2655 TDD B38/39/40/41    TD-LTE@B38(2600MHz)/B41(2500MHz)  TD-LTE@B38(2600MHz)/B41(2500MHz)
  UMTS band 2100/900MHz 3GPP R9 ,Category 4, DL 150Mbps  UL  50Mbps   – FDD-LTE Band 1/3 (1800/2100mhz) – FDD-LTE Band 1/3 (1800/2100mhz)
  GSM quad- band: 850/900/1800/1900MHz Band FDD B3/7/20 or FDD B28  or FDD B1/B3/B5   – CDMA: BC0/BC1 – CDMA: BC0/BC2
  LTE FDD: DL/UL 150/50Mbps   – GSM@B8(900MHz)/B3(1800MHz)/B2(1900MHz) – GSM@B8(900MHz)/B3(1800MHz)/B2(1900MHz)
  LTE TDD: DL/UL 110+/11+Mbps      
  DC-HSPA+: DL/UL 42/5.7Mbps      
  LTE: FDD B1/B3/B5/B8/B26; TDD B40 (2300–      
  2395 MHz); DC- HSPA+/HSPA+/H SPA/UMTS: B1/B5/B8; EDGE/GPRS/GSM      
  : B2/B3/B5/B8;      
WiFi Frequency  2.4 GHz ISM  2.400~2.484GHz      
Chipset ZTE ZTE ZTE ZTE ZTE
Antenna Built-in Built- in Built-in Built-in Built-in

 

Our Ratings

From the comparative analysis above, the Smile Router, based on technical features, is at the top of the list based on with exceptional features like; the long lasting inbuilt battery, Omni-directional antennas with a provision of 2 elongated ones for LTE to use in places with weak signal reception. With the exception of Smile, all the MNOs operate other network technologies which preceded 4G LTE (3G/2G) and as a result their devices fall back to 3G+/3G from 4G, which Smile’s does not provision for as its entire network consists of 4G LTE technology. In this context, for speed, efficiency and reliability and because the devices are all strictly 4G, Smile edges out competitors. However the MiFi routers of MTN and Airtel also performs very well compared to that of Smile.